I’m living the dream, I tell you! I’ve swapped my MacBook for a Dell Mini and so far the experience has been pretty positive. For anybody wondering about whether to get one or not, below is a collection of my thoughts:
Customer Service – e.g. Buying From Dell
Great. Ordered over the phone, and after mentioning that I was a student in one part of the conversation, I got a discount in another – an extra year’s warranty for £12 seems like good value to me. Also, the sales rep asked me if I needed the machine by a certain date, which I did, so they gave me priority order status and got the machine to me in under 5 days, compared to the advertised 15!
The other nice touch when buying over the phone with Dell was that the sales rep gave me his own extension, so that if I had any problems I could talk to the same person.
The Machine & Fedora
Fedora 9 fails to boot on a standard install as the kernel doesn’t support the network adapter used on the Atom motherboards, but more recent Fedora 9 and Fedora 10 kernels do. This leaves you with three ways to get Fedora installed:
- Install rawhide
- Create a respin of Fedora with the latest kernel and Anaconda updates from Unity
- Disable the ethernet in the bios for installation and update the kernel afterwards by downloading it from koji
Obviously, because there’s no optical drive you need to put your installation media onto a USB stick.
I opted for number three, and it worked perfectly.
The other major problem with the hardware is that the wireless chip is from Broadcom (bcm4310) and it doesn’t yet have a free driver, with the only support coming from ndiswrapper at the moment. Fortunately, wireless is provided by an easily accessible PCI-E slot, and I’ve just ordered an Intel 3945 from eBay for £7 which will work with free drivers.
Everything else seems to work perfectly: the webcam, the randomly placed function keys along the A – L row of key, bluetooth etc.
The Hardware Itself
Seems really well put together so far. It looks pretty nice, the hinge on the screen is extremely sturdy and the mouse buttons are placed exactly where you’d expect them to be, with a nice responsive mechanism underneath. The mouse pad is a little sticky feeling, but it seems to be getting better as I use it, so maybe that’s just because it’s new.
The keyboard is what concerns people most with these machines I think, but I’m happy to say that I could touch type on this almost straight away. The only keys that are giving me any trouble are the arrow keys and the right shift key, but I think I’ll get used to them soon. It’s not, however, a keyboard that I’d like to use as my primary system, and as I’m intending to use this as my primary machine, I’m buying a wireless keyboard and mouse.
I’m also buying an external monitor for use with it, as although the integrated screen is really nice, displaying everything I’ve thrown at it wonderfully, it is a little bit small for extended use.
All in all, I couldn’t be happier with it to be honest! I think it’s going to turn out to be far more practical, and make travelling a lot more pleasurable. I’ll post with more thoughts and feedback as I progress with the system, in what is admittedly a bit of an experiment to see how easy it is to live with a netbook as a primary machine.
To anyone who’s wondering about buying one (Max!), I’d definitely recomend it based on my experiences so far.
11 Comments
thanks for sharing, Jon. I’m glad to know the issues aren’t insurmountable, but it’s a bit frustrating that they existed to the level that they did. /me continues to think about what he wants to do.
Sounds good, Jon.
You mentioned you’re going to buy an external monitor. Any idea what the Dell’s maximum resolution is for an external monitor?
Thanks and have fun!
What’s battery life like?
Thanks for the info. Still waiting for delivery! No priority queue here.
Hi Jon,
I’m wanting to do exactly what you’ve described. I’ve gotten as far as installing the base Fedora 9 iso, but I get stuck when updating the kernel. I downloaded the latest FC9 2.6.26.5-47.fc9.i686.rpm from Koji but get this error when installing:
iwl4965-firmware < 228.57.2 conflicts with kernel-*as_above*
To update I use:
rpm -Uhv *kernel_package*
Is this because the wireless card was detected and installed on startup? In your instructions you said you only disabled the ethernet prior to installing, not the wireless. I’m guessing you didn’t come accross this error… What kernel did you update with? I’ve also tried the 2.6.26.5-45 kernel with the same error.
Thanks in advance,
Kris
Ah, I should have mentioned that in the post. I’m pretty sure iwl4965 is installed by default, as part of the ‘hardware support’ group. It’s not needed by this system, however, and so I just did ‘rpm -e iwl4965…’ and then installed the kernel.
Cheating I know, but it didn’t brake anything so it’s good to go
Thanks Jon
I found a forum thread (http://fedoraforum.org/forum/showthread.php?t=196828) that helped in the meantime. I essentially ended up doing what you suggested but also installed the latest compatible iwl4965-firmware just in case. Good to know I can just turf it if I want.
Thanks to you detailing your experience, I’ve now got FC9 up and running on my Mini ^^. Cheers!
Jon, have you had any luck with suspending to RAM or disk on the Mini under FC9?
Yeah, suspend seems to work perfectly, though I haven’t tried hibernate. I’ve got it set up so it suspends when I close the lid and I have no problems.
Sweet! Checked suspend: works flawlessly. Re-checked hibernate: also works flawlessly
; I was just being impatient with the save to disk (there’s no progress identifier).
thanks for all the ifo, Nikil. I’ll get my Uber-geek husband right on it! I love it too. As for the battery life, I have been taking lecture notes on a fully charged battery for 1 1/2 hours and I am now at 51%. Dell is not selling extra batteries yet, so they told me.
However, as for the wireless mouse, the one I ordered from Dell to go with my Mini9 (Umbutu) quit working completely by the third day. The touchpad is WAY too sensitive and adjusting the setting doesn’t do anything. Hate the location of the apostrophe/quote key!!! Other than these goofy details, I LOVE THIS NOTEBOOK. Had an ASUS but have not tried HP. This one is worth giving my man a headache over.
4 Trackbacks/Pingbacks
[...] nikil.v: The other major problem with the hardware is that the wireless chip is from Broadcom (bcm4310) and it doesn’t yet have a free driver, with the only support coming from ndiswrapper at the moment. Fortunately, wireless is provided by an … [...]
[...] Dell Mini Inspiron 9 I’m living the dream, I tell you! I’ve swapped my MacBook for a Dell Mini and so far the experience has been pretty positive. [...]
[...] quite a cracker). It appears some XP-model Mini owners have had some success installing Fedora 9 (here and here – both bloggers are named John/Jon; conspiracy? You decide…). The main issues [...]
[...] USB memory stick, but figuring out how for a specific distro can be troublesome. In the end I found the advice of JonRob to be the best (some parts involving the installation of Fedora below are from his hints – [...]